[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":428},["ShallowReactive",2],{"insight-saas-vs-custom":3,"insight-related-saas-vs-custom":156},{"_path":4,"_dir":5,"_draft":6,"_partial":6,"_locale":7,"title":8,"description":7,"slug":9,"date":10,"duration":11,"category":12,"author":13,"tags":14,"body":19,"_type":150,"_id":151,"_source":152,"_file":153,"_stem":154,"_extension":155},"\u002Finsights\u002F10-saas-vs-custom","insights",false,"","SaaS or 自研：一个简单的决策框架","saas-vs-custom","2025-04-30",8,"业务咨询","浩途方法论",[15,16,17,18],"SaaS","自研","选型","决策框架",{"type":20,"children":21,"toc":143},"root",[22,30,43,47,53,65,100,105,108,114,123,126,131],{"type":23,"tag":24,"props":25,"children":27},"element","h2",{"id":26},"引子",[28],{"type":29,"value":26},"text",{"type":23,"tag":31,"props":32,"children":33},"p",{},[34,36,41],{"type":29,"value":35},"客户来咨询时，问的最多的问题之一是\"我们这种规模，应该上 SaaS 还是自研？\"\n没有标准答案，但有标准的",{"type":23,"tag":37,"props":38,"children":39},"strong",{},[40],{"type":29,"value":18},{"type":29,"value":42},"。这篇文章给出浩途多年沉淀的三条红线 + 一张矩阵。",{"type":23,"tag":44,"props":45,"children":46},"hr",{},[],{"type":23,"tag":24,"props":48,"children":50},{"id":49},"三条红线先看是否触发",[51],{"type":29,"value":52},"三条红线：先看是否触发",{"type":23,"tag":31,"props":54,"children":55},{},[56,58,63],{"type":29,"value":57},"如果触发任意一条，",{"type":23,"tag":37,"props":59,"children":60},{},[61],{"type":29,"value":62},"直接选自研",{"type":29,"value":64},"：",{"type":23,"tag":66,"props":67,"children":68},"ol",{},[69,80,90],{"type":23,"tag":70,"props":71,"children":72},"li",{},[73,78],{"type":23,"tag":37,"props":74,"children":75},{},[76],{"type":29,"value":77},"核心业务流程独特",{"type":29,"value":79},"且确实差异化（伪差异化不算）",{"type":23,"tag":70,"props":81,"children":82},{},[83,88],{"type":23,"tag":37,"props":84,"children":85},{},[86],{"type":29,"value":87},"数据敏感度极高",{"type":29,"value":89},"（金融核心、政务、个人医疗）",{"type":23,"tag":70,"props":91,"children":92},{},[93,98],{"type":23,"tag":37,"props":94,"children":95},{},[96],{"type":29,"value":97},"集成深度极深",{"type":29,"value":99},"（要打通 5+ 个内部系统）",{"type":23,"tag":31,"props":101,"children":102},{},[103],{"type":29,"value":104},"否则进入决策矩阵。",{"type":23,"tag":44,"props":106,"children":107},{},[],{"type":23,"tag":24,"props":109,"children":111},{"id":110},"决策矩阵业务成熟度-用户量级",[112],{"type":29,"value":113},"决策矩阵：业务成熟度 × 用户量级",{"type":23,"tag":115,"props":116,"children":117},"blockquote",{},[118],{"type":23,"tag":31,"props":119,"children":120},{},[121],{"type":29,"value":122},"（二维矩阵：业务流程是否标准 × 用户数量级，落到 4 象限，每个象限给出 SaaS \u002F 自研 \u002F 混合\n推荐。详细矩阵图与案例后续补充）",{"type":23,"tag":44,"props":124,"children":125},{},[],{"type":23,"tag":24,"props":127,"children":129},{"id":128},"写在最后",[130],{"type":29,"value":128},{"type":23,"tag":31,"props":132,"children":133},{},[134,136,141],{"type":29,"value":135},"最差的选项不是\"选错了\"，而是\"什么都没选清就开始动\"。",{"type":23,"tag":37,"props":137,"children":138},{},[139],{"type":29,"value":140},"先用 30 分钟讨论框架，\n再立项",{"type":29,"value":142},"——这是浩途免费送给所有 prospects 的方法论之一。",{"title":7,"searchDepth":144,"depth":144,"links":145},2,[146,147,148,149],{"id":26,"depth":144,"text":26},{"id":49,"depth":144,"text":52},{"id":110,"depth":144,"text":113},{"id":128,"depth":144,"text":128},"markdown","content:insights:10-saas-vs-custom.md","content","insights\u002F10-saas-vs-custom.md","insights\u002F10-saas-vs-custom","md",[157,278],{"_path":158,"_dir":5,"_draft":6,"_partial":6,"_locale":7,"title":159,"description":7,"slug":160,"date":161,"duration":162,"category":12,"author":163,"tags":164,"featured":169,"body":170,"_type":150,"_id":275,"_source":152,"_file":276,"_stem":277,"_extension":155},"\u002Finsights\u002F02-system-selection-trap","为什么\"先选系统\"几乎总是失败的开始？","system-selection-trap","2026-03-02",9,"浩途咨询团队",[165,166,167,168],"信息化","流程","ERP","OA",true,{"type":20,"children":171,"toc":268},[172,177,182,185,191,196,215,218,224,229,232,238,243,246,251,263],{"type":23,"tag":24,"props":173,"children":175},{"id":174},"一个常见的开局",[176],{"type":29,"value":174},{"type":23,"tag":31,"props":178,"children":179},{},[180],{"type":29,"value":181},"\"我们想上一套 ERP，请你来给推荐几个候选厂商。\"——这是浩途收到客户咨询时最常见的开场白之一。\n但凡这句话出现，我们基本能预判后续会遇到三个坑。",{"type":23,"tag":44,"props":183,"children":184},{},[],{"type":23,"tag":24,"props":186,"children":188},{"id":187},"坑一当前流程没盘清",[189],{"type":29,"value":190},"坑一：当前流程没盘清",{"type":23,"tag":31,"props":192,"children":193},{},[194],{"type":29,"value":195},"任何企业都有一套\"事实上的运行规则\"——纸面上的流程图与实际执行常常对不上。\n直接让一套通用 ERP 套上来，三个月后会发现：",{"type":23,"tag":197,"props":198,"children":199},"ul",{},[200,205,210],{"type":23,"tag":70,"props":201,"children":202},{},[203],{"type":29,"value":204},"业务部门绕过系统在用 Excel",{"type":23,"tag":70,"props":206,"children":207},{},[208],{"type":29,"value":209},"关键审批流没人理",{"type":23,"tag":70,"props":211,"children":212},{},[213],{"type":29,"value":214},"数据口径打架",{"type":23,"tag":44,"props":216,"children":217},{},[],{"type":23,"tag":24,"props":219,"children":221},{"id":220},"坑二把管理变革和系统建设混为一谈",[222],{"type":29,"value":223},"坑二：把\"管理变革\"和\"系统建设\"混为一谈",{"type":23,"tag":31,"props":225,"children":226},{},[227],{"type":29,"value":228},"\"上 ERP\" 本质上是一次管理变革——重新定义职责边界、流程、数据口径。\n但很多企业把它当成 IT 项目交给信息部，结果是 IT 撂挑子，业务部反对，老板买单。",{"type":23,"tag":44,"props":230,"children":231},{},[],{"type":23,"tag":24,"props":233,"children":235},{"id":234},"坑三选型先于需求确认",[236],{"type":29,"value":237},"坑三：选型先于需求确认",{"type":23,"tag":31,"props":239,"children":240},{},[241],{"type":29,"value":242},"\"功能模块越多越好\"是采购方常见误区。结果买回来 80% 用不上、20% 不够用。",{"type":23,"tag":44,"props":244,"children":245},{},[],{"type":23,"tag":24,"props":247,"children":249},{"id":248},"浩途的做法",[250],{"type":29,"value":248},{"type":23,"tag":31,"props":252,"children":253},{},[254,256,261],{"type":29,"value":255},"我们坚持：\"",{"type":23,"tag":37,"props":257,"children":258},{},[259],{"type":29,"value":260},"敲下第一行代码之前，先把业务图画清",{"type":29,"value":262},"\"。",{"type":23,"tag":31,"props":264,"children":265},{},[266],{"type":29,"value":267},"具体执行上：先做 2-3 周的业务诊断，输出现状流程图与目标流程图，\n让客户的业务部门、IT 部门、决策层在同一张图上对齐——再谈系统选型，\n往往会发现：\"其实只需要做 A 与 B，C 完全没必要\"。",{"title":7,"searchDepth":144,"depth":144,"links":269},[270,271,272,273,274],{"id":174,"depth":144,"text":174},{"id":187,"depth":144,"text":190},{"id":220,"depth":144,"text":223},{"id":234,"depth":144,"text":237},{"id":248,"depth":144,"text":248},"content:insights:02-system-selection-trap.md","insights\u002F02-system-selection-trap.md","insights\u002F02-system-selection-trap",{"_path":279,"_dir":5,"_draft":6,"_partial":6,"_locale":7,"title":280,"description":7,"slug":281,"date":282,"duration":283,"category":12,"author":13,"tags":284,"featured":6,"body":287,"_type":150,"_id":425,"_source":152,"_file":426,"_stem":427,"_extension":155},"\u002Finsights\u002F08-business-graph","业务图谱：在写代码之前，先把业务画清","business-graph","2025-09-12",10,[285,286,12],"业务图谱","方法论",{"type":20,"children":288,"toc":419},[289,293,305,308,313,366,369,374,392,400,403,407],{"type":23,"tag":24,"props":290,"children":291},{"id":26},[292],{"type":29,"value":26},{"type":23,"tag":31,"props":294,"children":295},{},[296,298,303],{"type":29,"value":297},"客户找浩途时，需求往往以\"做一个 XX 系统\"开头。我们的回答多数是：",{"type":23,"tag":37,"props":299,"children":300},{},[301],{"type":29,"value":302},"\"先别写代码。\n先用 2 周把业务画清。\"",{"type":29,"value":304}," 这是浩途方法论里\"业务先行\"原则的具体落地——业务图谱。",{"type":23,"tag":44,"props":306,"children":307},{},[],{"type":23,"tag":24,"props":309,"children":311},{"id":310},"业务图谱要画哪些层",[312],{"type":29,"value":310},{"type":23,"tag":66,"props":314,"children":315},{},[316,326,336,346,356],{"type":23,"tag":70,"props":317,"children":318},{},[319,324],{"type":23,"tag":37,"props":320,"children":321},{},[322],{"type":29,"value":323},"角色层",{"type":29,"value":325},"：谁参与，每个角色的目标和约束",{"type":23,"tag":70,"props":327,"children":328},{},[329,334],{"type":23,"tag":37,"props":330,"children":331},{},[332],{"type":29,"value":333},"流程层",{"type":29,"value":335},"：业务从触发到结果的关键节点",{"type":23,"tag":70,"props":337,"children":338},{},[339,344],{"type":23,"tag":37,"props":340,"children":341},{},[342],{"type":29,"value":343},"数据层",{"type":29,"value":345},"：每个节点流转的数据是什么、归属谁",{"type":23,"tag":70,"props":347,"children":348},{},[349,354],{"type":23,"tag":37,"props":350,"children":351},{},[352],{"type":29,"value":353},"决策层",{"type":29,"value":355},"：哪些节点是\"判断分叉\"，规则怎么写",{"type":23,"tag":70,"props":357,"children":358},{},[359,364],{"type":23,"tag":37,"props":360,"children":361},{},[362],{"type":29,"value":363},"异常层",{"type":29,"value":365},"：常见的不顺、回退、人工介入路径",{"type":23,"tag":44,"props":367,"children":368},{},[],{"type":23,"tag":24,"props":370,"children":372},{"id":371},"画完之后能做什么",[373],{"type":29,"value":371},{"type":23,"tag":197,"props":375,"children":376},{},[377,382,387],{"type":23,"tag":70,"props":378,"children":379},{},[380],{"type":29,"value":381},"看出哪些环节根本不需要系统化（用一个表格就够）",{"type":23,"tag":70,"props":383,"children":384},{},[385],{"type":29,"value":386},"看出哪些环节是真正的瓶颈，值得投入 80% 的资源",{"type":23,"tag":70,"props":388,"children":389},{},[390],{"type":29,"value":391},"看出系统边界——什么是 in scope，什么是别的系统的事",{"type":23,"tag":115,"props":393,"children":394},{},[395],{"type":23,"tag":31,"props":396,"children":397},{},[398],{"type":29,"value":399},"（配套模板与真实项目案例后续展开）",{"type":23,"tag":44,"props":401,"children":402},{},[],{"type":23,"tag":24,"props":404,"children":405},{"id":128},[406],{"type":29,"value":128},{"type":23,"tag":31,"props":408,"children":409},{},[410,412,417],{"type":29,"value":411},"代码贵的从来不是写代码本身，而是\"业务理解错了又写一遍\"。",{"type":23,"tag":37,"props":413,"children":414},{},[415],{"type":29,"value":416},"业务图谱不是浪费时间，\n是省时间的方式",{"type":29,"value":418},"。",{"title":7,"searchDepth":144,"depth":144,"links":420},[421,422,423,424],{"id":26,"depth":144,"text":26},{"id":310,"depth":144,"text":310},{"id":371,"depth":144,"text":371},{"id":128,"depth":144,"text":128},"content:insights:08-business-graph.md","insights\u002F08-business-graph.md","insights\u002F08-business-graph",1780542369011]